Expert travertine tile comparison – Best 4 for 2025

Natural stone and premium tile can completely change the look and feel of any home or commercial space. Whether you are starting a kitchen remodel or planning a large-scale project, the details of surface materials make all the difference. It can be tricky to choose between authentic stone, custom mosaics, curated collections, or new design tools when each option promises something different. Top suppliers offer everything from rapid shipping to hands-on design consultations and free samples, making it easier yet sometimes more confusing to pick the right fit. Are you curious which sources really deliver on variety, quality, and service? Take a closer look to see how the most popular choices compare.

Table of Contents

• Surfaces Galore
• Travertine Market
• MSI Surfaces
• The Tile Shop

Surfaces Galore

At a Glance

Surfaces Galore is a focused, premium supplier of natural stone that makes high-end materials accessible to designers, contractors, and homeowners. The company combines direct-import pricing with fast, insured shipping and robust customer support, which shortens lead times and reduces project risk. If you need authentic marble or travertine with custom mosaic options and a variety of finishes, Surfaces Galore is a top-tier, practical choice.

Core Features

Surfaces Galore offers a wide selection of marble, travertine, limestone, soapstone, quartz, and granite available in polished, honed, brushed, split face, textured, and tumbled finishes. Their catalog includes custom mosaics and patterned tiles, plus accessories tailored to installation needs. Operational strengths include fast, insured shipping with same-day dispatch on most orders, a price match guarantee, and free samples on request—features that directly address scheduling, risk, and color-matching challenges on real projects.

Pros

• Extensive product selection: The broad range of natural stones and finishes supports cohesive design across floors, walls, and backsplashes without resorting to synthetic materials.
• Rapid, insured shipping: Same-day dispatch on most orders and insured delivery reduce downtime and protect expensive shipments during transit.
• Natural-stone focus ensures authenticity: By concentrating exclusively on natural stone, the company delivers depth of expertise and consistent material quality for luxury projects.
• Responsive customer service: Designers and contractors report helpful guidance during material selection, which speeds decision-making and minimizes costly mistakes.
• Competitive pricing and discounts: Direct import model and clearance sales offer significant savings—especially for projects that can take advantage of up to 50% off clearance inventory.

Who It’s For

Surfaces Galore is ideal for homeowners, interior designers, architects, contractors, and renovation enthusiasts who prioritize authentic natural stone and reliable fulfillment. It particularly suits projects where timelines and material integrity matter—kitchen and bathroom remodels, luxury hospitality finishes, and commercial interiors where coordinated stone selections are required.

Unique Value Proposition

Surfaces Galore is a leading direct importer of premium natural stone, specializing in marble and travertine tiles, mosaics, and decorative pieces. Based in Anaheim, California, we proudly ship nationwide to designers, architects, contractors, and homeowners seeking quality and style. Our mission is to provide authentic, durable, and elegant natural stone at affordable prices, helping every project achieve timeless beauty. What sets Surfaces Galore apart is the combination of direct-import economics, a specialized natural-stone-only inventory, and operational reliability—fast, insured shipping and same-day dispatch remove common vendor friction. Add free samples, a price-match guarantee, and custom mosaic capability, and you get a supplier that both simplifies specification and scales from single-tile accent walls to full commercial installations.

Real World Use Case

A homeowner renovating a kitchen selects marble tiles for a backsplash through Surfaces Galore, orders free samples to confirm veining and sheen, then relies on fast, insured shipping to meet a tight contractor schedule. Expert support helps refine edge details and mosaic patterning, so the final installation arrives on time and matches the design intent.

Pricing

Quote-based — pricing varies depending on the product and size, with discounts available up to 50% on clearance items.

Website: https://surfacesgalore.com

Travertine Market

At a Glance

Travertine Market is a Southern California–based supplier of in-stock travertine, marble tiles, pavers, and mosaics that has served homeowners and professionals since 2004. Its clear strengths are a deep, ready-to-ship inventory and a hands-on showroom experience in Anaheim, backed by personalized guidance and fast fulfillment. If you need authentic stone sourced directly from quarries and want to see real samples before committing, Travertine Market delivers — but its online visualization tools are limited and its services are strongest for local projects.

Core Features

Travertine Market stocks a wide range of natural stone products, including outdoor collections, mosaics, and complementary items like luxury vinyl. They offer custom sourcing and cutting from their existing inventory, and samples are cut from actual stock so color and veining match what you’ll install. The Anaheim showroom enables in-person consultation and material viewing, while local pickup and fast fulfillment options speed project timelines. The company positions itself as both a retail and professional resource, combining catalog breadth with project-level support.

Pros

• Extensive inventory of natural stones: A large, in-stock selection reduces lead times and simplifies material matching for complex projects.
• Expert guidance and personalized service: Staffed consultation at the showroom helps you evaluate finish, edge profiles, and installation considerations.
• Fast order fulfillment and local pickup options: Ready stock and local logistics accelerate schedules for remodels and commercial jobs.
• Authentic, high-quality stone from trusted quarries: Direct sourcing supports consistent material quality and a more transparent supply chain.
• Deep product knowledge and project support: The team’s experience is useful for specifying stone for wet areas, outdoor pavers, or architectural features.

Cons

• Limited online visualization options for final products: You may not be able to preview large-format layouts or simulated finishes digitally before visiting the showroom.
• Potentially higher costs for custom orders or unique stones: Custom sourcing and special cuts can increase project costs, depending on material rarity and labor.
• Services primarily centered around Southern California: National shipping exists, but the strongest support and fastest fulfillment are local to Anaheim and surrounding areas.

Who It’s For

Travertine Market is ideal for homeowners, contractors, designers, and architects who prioritize authentic natural stone, rapid availability, and the ability to inspect real samples in person. It particularly suits projects based in or near Southern California where showroom access and local pickup will materially reduce risk and lead time.

Unique Value Proposition

The company blends a generously stocked natural stone inventory with in-person showroom access and custom cutting from actual stock. That combination lets professionals and homeowners confirm color and texture before purchase and move from selection to delivery more quickly than many custom-import options.

Real World Use Case

A homeowner in Anaheim can consult in the showroom, review samples cut from the exact tiles in inventory, choose a marble tile for a bathroom renovation, and arrange same-week pickup or local delivery to meet a tight remodel schedule.

Pricing

Prices vary by product, and sale discounts are offered on selected items such as marble tiles, wall panels, and stacked stones.

Website: https://travertinemarket.com

MSI Surfaces

At a Glance

MSI Surfaces presents a broad, trade-ready catalog of countertops, flooring, backsplash tile, and hardscaping materials backed by a long industry history. The company pairs an extensive product selection with practical design tools—like a multi-surface visualizer and virtual kitchen designer—to help you preview layouts before committing. MSI’s nationwide showroom and dealer network supports both residential and commercial projects, but be prepared to rely on dealers or in-person visits for the full specification and purchasing experience. Bottom line: a powerful resource for designers and contractors who value selection and visualization, though online detail and direct e-commerce are limited.

Core Features

MSI’s core capabilities center on variety, visualization, and distribution. Their catalog spans porcelain pavers, wood-look planks, mosaic tiles, marble, quartz, natural stone countertops, and hardscape products, plus waterproof flooring options such as Everlife®. Design support includes a multi-surface visualizer and a virtual kitchen designer, and the brand supplements those tools with educational videos, countertop guides, and inspiration galleries. Finally, MSI maintains multiple showrooms and dealer locations across the U.S. and Canada, making physical product inspection accessible for professionals and homeowners.

Pros

• Extensive product variety and brand offerings give you more material and finish choices for matching project aesthetics and performance requirements.
• Innovative design tools and visualization resources let you preview combinations and reduce surprises during installation.
• Strong distribution network with numerous showrooms ensures hands-on inspection is feasible for designers, contractors, and clients.
• Decades of industry experience—MSI has been operating since 1975—translate into proven sourcing, logistics, and product knowledge.
• A clear focus on style, quality, and innovation means the catalog stays current with market trends and practical solutions like waterproof flooring.

Cons

• The website lacks comprehensive, detailed product specifications, which means you may not find all technical data online before contacting a dealer.
• Some product information requires direct contact or a showroom visit to confirm finish options, thicknesses, or installation details.
• Online purchasing options are limited because the company emphasizes showroom and dealer sales, which can slow procurement for quick-turn projects.

Who It’s For

MSI Surfaces is best suited for homeowners, interior designers, architects, and contractors who need a wide palette of natural and engineered surface options and who value in-person selection. If you specify materials for kitchens, bathrooms, hospitality, retail, or outdoor living spaces, MSI’s selection and visualization tools will streamline decision-making—especially when paired with a local dealer or showroom visit.

Unique Value Proposition

MSI’s unique strength lies in combining an expansive, trend-aware product line with practical visualization tools and a deep showroom network. That mix lets design professionals and homeowners preview, vet, and source premium surfaces while relying on established distribution channels and decades of industry know-how.

Real World Use Case

A homeowner planning a kitchen remodel can use MSI’s virtual kitchen designer to test quartz countertop visuals alongside Everlife® waterproof flooring options, shortlist materials, then visit a nearby showroom to confirm samples, measurements, and installation details before ordering through a local dealer.

Pricing

Quote-based. Pricing is not explicitly listed online and likely varies by product, finish, and dealer.

Website: https://msisurfaces.com

The Tile Shop

At a Glance

The Tile Shop presents a broad, design-forward selection of floor and wall tiles that suits both straightforward remodels and ambitious custom schemes. Its strengths are the depth of exclusive collections and the free design consultation services—online or in-store—that guide decision-making. The site emphasizes inspiration and visualization tools rather than hard pricing, which helps spark ideas but leaves budget planning for later.

Core Features

The Tile Shop combines a large curated assortment—ceramic, porcelain, stone, vinyl, and more—with practical tools to move a project from concept to execution. Key capabilities include an exclusive collection of 250+ ceramic essentials for mixing and matching, a tile visualizer to preview combinations, a customer room gallery for real-life examples, and the option to schedule free consultations with tile experts either online or in person. These elements are directed at helping you visualize layouts, test palettes, and validate choices before committing to material quantities.

See samples first.

Pros

• Wide variety of exclusive and designer collections: The Tile Shop offers an extensive catalog that makes it easier to find coordinated looks and unique pieces without hunting multiple vendors.
• Free design consultations available online and in store: You can leverage expert input at no extra cost, which reduces guesswork on layout, grout, and finish decisions.
• Helpful resources like blogs, tutorials, and customer galleries: Educational content and real project photos speed up inspiration and practical planning.
• Ability to get samples delivered directly to your doorstep: Sampling reduces risk by letting you check color and texture in your actual light conditions.
• Active on social media for latest updates: Regular updates and user posts help you track trends and new drops from their exclusive collections.

Cons

• Website does not specify detailed pricing or product availability: The lack of clear price listings means you may need to contact a store or consultant to confirm budget and stock.
• Limited information on specific tile materials and sizes: Product pages can leave critical technical details unclear, which complicates specification for installers and architects.
• Potential need for in-person visits to see full product range: To evaluate full collections and tactile qualities you may still need to visit a showroom despite the online tools.

Who It’s For

The Tile Shop is tailored for homeowners, interior designers, and contractors who prioritize curated design options plus hands-on guidance. If you value curated collections, visual tools, and access to expert consultations to refine choices, this service fits well. If you need immediate, line-item pricing or exhaustive technical specs online, you may find the experience incomplete without a follow-up.

Unique Value Proposition

The Tile Shop’s edge is its combination of exclusive, mix-and-match tile collections with practical design support—free consultations, a visualizer, and customer galleries—so you can move from idea to validated design with less friction. It’s a design-first approach backed by expert touchpoints.

Real World Use Case

A homeowner planning a kitchen backsplash can browse curated options, view similar installs in the customer gallery, schedule a free consultation to confirm layout and grout, order samples, and use the tile visualizer to finalize the exact pattern before purchase.

Pricing

Pricing: Not specified on the website; promotional and sale items are generally available.

Website: https://tileshop.com

Natural Stone Suppliers Comparison

Below is a comparison table summarizing the key features, strengths, and considerations for each natural stone supplier reviewed in the article. This will help you quickly compare your options based on their unique offerings and pricing models.

Supplier	Core Features	Pros	Cons	Pricing
Surfaces Galore	Marble, travertine, limestone, and more; fast, insured shipping	Extensive selection; rapid shipping; natural-stone focus; responsive customer service; competitive pricing	Not specified	Quote-based; up to 50% off
Travertine Market	Wide range of in-stock natural stones; showroom in Anaheim	Extensive inventory; expert guidance; fast fulfillment; high-quality stone; project support	Limited online visualization; higher costs possible for custom orders; services centered around Southern California	Varied by product
MSI Surfaces	Countertops, flooring, backsplash tiles; multi-surface visualizer; nationwide showrooms	Product variety; design tools; strong distribution network; decades of experience; style focus	Limited online product details; reliance on showrooms for certain info; limited online purchasing	Quote-based
The Tile Shop	Floor and wall tiles; exclusive collections; free design consultations	Wide variety; free consultations; helpful resources; sample delivery; active social media presence	No detailed pricing online; limited tile material and size info; may require in-person visits	Not specified

Discover the Perfect Travertine Tile for Your Next Project

Choosing the right travertine tile means balancing authenticity, durability, and style—challenges that every designer, contractor, or homeowner faces. The article “Expert travertine tile comparison – Best 4 for 2025” highlights the importance of selecting natural stone that not only fits your aesthetic vision but also delivers reliability and timely fulfillment. Key concerns like authentic sourcing, varied finishes, and quick delivery can make or break your remodeling or building experience.

At Surfaces Galore, we understand these pain points. Our exclusive focus on premium natural stones like travertine and marble ensures you get authentic, high-quality materials that elevate any space. With fast, insured shipping and the ability to order free samples for color validation, we help you avoid costly delays and mismatches. Explore our collection of natural stone tiles and experience firsthand the timeless beauty that only genuine travertine can provide.

Ready to bring your vision to life with confidence?

Unlock the full potential of your project by starting today with Surfaces Galore.

Browse our selection at Surfaces Galore and enjoy a smooth, trustworthy path from design through installation. Let us be your partner for exquisite travertine tiles delivered on your schedule.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the key characteristics to look for in travertine tiles for my project?

When choosing travertine tiles, focus on thickness, finish options, and veining patterns. Evaluate these factors against your project’s design requirements, and select tiles that match both aesthetic preferences and practical durability needs.

How do I determine the best travertine tile finish for my specific application?

The best finish depends on the tile’s intended use: polished tiles offer a shiny, formal look, while honed tiles provide a more natural appearance with better slip resistance. Assess the area’s functionality—like high-traffic zones or wet areas—and choose the finish that enhances both beauty and safety.

What maintenance practices should I adopt for travertine tiles?

To maintain travertine tiles, clean them regularly with a pH-neutral cleaner and avoid acidic substances that can etch the surface. Establish a routine cleaning schedule and reseal the tiles every 6-12 months to protect against stains and moisture.

How can I compare different travertine tiles effectively?

Effective comparison involves assessing material quality, price per square foot, and specific performance characteristics like suitability for indoor vs. outdoor use. Create a side-by-side chart to track these criteria for each tile and make informed selections based on your project’s requirements.

Are there specific design trends for travertine tiles to consider in 2025?

Yes, in 2025, expect to see a rise in the popularity of larger format tiles and unique patterns, such as diagonal layouts, that enhance visual interest. Review current design trends to ensure your selections will align with popular aesthetics while also meeting your functional needs.

How do I calculate the amount of travertine tile I need for my project?

Calculate the total square footage of the area by measuring length and width, then multiply those figures to find the area. Add an additional 10% for waste and cuts, ensuring you have enough material to complete your installation successfully.

Recommended

• Travertine Tile Finishes: Complete Guide for 2025
• Travertine Flooring for Timeless Beauty and Value
• Master the Travertine Tiling Process for Stunning Results
• What Is Travertine? Complete Overview for Designers